Not quite two weeks into the open season on the possible reversal of the Capline pipeline, the rationale for the move is clear. The question is whether shippers will support it.
The answer will come by Nov. 17, when the season closes for the northbound pipeline, which currently runs from Louisiana to Illinois.
Shipper support will be part of the answer to whether the long-contemplated move is a savvy and efficient redevelopment of a major asset, or just a last-ditch effort to salvage some value for a line that has seen dwindling shipments.
Marathon Pipe Line LLC, operator of the 40-inch, 1.2 million-barrel-per-day Capline, announced a non-binding open season Oct. 17 to gauge shipper interest in a proposed reversal. The plan is to flip the line and ship from Patoka, Ill. to St. James, La., and then to either Gulf Coast refineries or waterborne export markets.
If the owners—Plains All American Pipeline (NYSE: PAA) (54%), Marathon Petroleum (33%) and BP Oil Pipeline Co. (13%)—decide to proceed, southbound flow could be operational by second-half 2022. Once in southbound service, Capline would have an initial capacity up to 300,000 barrels per day (bbl/d).
The reversed pipeline would be able to receive crude from connecting carriers at Patoka. At St. James, shippers would have access to a distribution network that includes refineries, terminals, ships, barges and rail.
Even in announcing the open season, Marathon acknowledged that “the pipeline was once a major transportation route for delivering crude that was imported or produced in the Gulf of Mexico to refineries in the
An Oct. 23 analysis by Morningstar measured that decline in throughput from about 1 million bbl/d in 2000 to about 550,000 bbl/d in 2010. Volume then tumbled, bottoming out at about 250,000 bbl/d in 2012, a mere quarter of the peak. Since then throughput recovered modestly, to about 350,000 bbl/d in 2016. That is expected to remain roughly flat for this year, based on actual shipment through August.
Morningstar noted that “Capline shipments showed some improvement as
Observers have noted that the initial southbound capacity is planned for 300,000 bbl/d, which is nominally less that current northbound actual shipments. Supporters of the project note that northbound business is more likely to shrink than to grow, while the southbound capacity could easily be expanded as commitments grow.
Not all are convinced, including Sandy Fielden, director of oil and products research for Morningstar.
“While the reversal proposal is a shock to no one, the lengthy five-year gestation period before it happens and the limited 300,000 bbl/d proposed southbound capacity have raised eyebrows,” he wrote in the report. “We believe these represent necessary caution by the partners. That’s because demand for southbound capacity from the Midwest to the Louisiana Gulf Coast is currently saturated and is unlikely to pick up before the early 2020s—and even then, it will not come close to Capline’s full 1.2 million bbl/d capacity.”
The obvious crudes looking for southbound routes are growing western Canadian production, as well as
“Producers of both these crudes have been anxious to find routes to export markets,” Fielden wrote. They “could benefit from a Capline reversal that would offer tidewater access if combined with the proposed
Recommended Reading
Oil Dips as Demand Outlook Remains Uncertain
2024-02-20 - Oil prices fell on Feb. 20 with an uncertain outlook for global demand knocking value off crude futures contracts.
What's Affecting Oil Prices This Week? (Feb. 26, 2024)
2024-02-26 - Stratas Advisors forecast that global crude production will be essentially unchanged from 2023, which means that demand growth in 2024 will outpace supply growth.
Oil Rises After OPEC+ Extends Output Cuts
2024-03-04 - Rising geopolitical tensions due to the Israel-Hamas conflict and Houthi attacks on Red Sea shipping have supported oil prices in 2024, although concern about economic growth has weighed.
Global Oil Demand to Grow by 1.9 MMbbl/d in 2024, Says Wood Mac
2024-02-29 - Oil prices have found support this year from rising geopolitical tensions including attacks by the Iran-aligned Houthi group on Red Sea shipping.
US Gulf Coast Heavy Crude Oil Prices Firm as Supplies Tighten
2024-04-10 - Pushing up heavy crude prices are falling oil exports from Mexico, the potential for resumption of sanctions on Venezuelan crude, the imminent startup of a Canadian pipeline and continued output cuts by OPEC+.