With midstream MLP prices having recovered about 40% since their February lows but still about 40% from previous highs in August 2014, the industry has hit a sweet spot for M&A pricing. The unit prices of some companies are still low enough and their futures still uncertain enough to make them targets. On the other hand, the unit prices of some companies have recovered enough, and their manage- ment teams have enough faith in the stability of future expecta- tions, to make the companies willing to take the measured risk of being an acquirer.
On a strategic level, U.S. energy is experiencing a paradigm shift. Previously unimagined commodity price levels have removed the asymptotic growth once found in shale plays. Envi- ronmental protests that were formerly limited to the odd coal mine are now focused on pipelines and receiving major media attention. Socially responsible investors, once an elite set that could afford to stagnate fortunes in favor of naive ideals, are outperforming many major indexes. In this new world, with fewer major oil and gas infrastructure projects, large MLPs and energy companies whose investors are accustomed to steady growth are now reaching beyond just rolling up mom & pop businesses or building add-on assets.
The merger between Energy Transfer Equity LP and The Wil- liams Cos. Inc. fell through despite strategic benefits. Technically, the failure was due to the lack of a necessary tax opinion; practically, it was the cash component. In another instance, Enterprise Prod- ucts Partners LP’s bid for Williams never got further than a nonbind- ing proposal due to lack of interest from Enterprise’s own investors and Williams itself.
Both Kinder Morgan Inc. and Plains All American Pipeline LP completed their own internal mergers, removing the old industry joke of an eventual All American Kinderprise Partners.
Canadian companies have been more successful. TransCanada Corp. bought Columbia Pipeline Group Inc. and, as we went to print, Enbridge Inc. announced the acquisition of Spectra Energy Corp. Despite the Canadian/U.S. dollar exchange rate, Canada’s two midstream majors have strong balance sheets.
The simplest mergers are between two standalone entities. The quest for simplicity—and understandability—was one driver of the Kinder Morgan and Plains All American mergers. Mergers between general partners (such as Energy Transfer Equity and Wil- liams) get complicated quickly; however, Enbridge and Spectra are both GPs. Their merger collectively involved eight different pub- licly traded companies—proof that long-term strategic benefits outweigh lawyers’ fees.
Regardless, if the global opportunity set (okay, the North American opportunity set) is limited, combining two companies achieves little more than pushing out the growth stagnation dead- line. It could be enough time for commodity prices to hit their own sweet spot of profitable drilling and low-cost consumption. With 10 years of planned growth, investors can breathe easier.
Maria Halmo is the director of research at Alerian, an independent provider of MLP and energy infrastructure market intelligence. Over $15 billion is directly tied to the Alerian Index Series. For additional commentary and research, visit www.alerian.com/alerian-insights.
Recommended Reading
The Secret to Record US Oil Output? Drilling Efficiencies—EIA
2024-03-06 - Advances in horizontal drilling and fracking technologies are yielding more efficient oil wells in the U.S. even as the rig count plummets, the Energy Information Administration reported.
WTI Delivered to East Houston Hits Highest Premium in Nearly Three Years
2024-05-01 - Oil takeaway capacity from the Permian Basin will tighten next month due to scheduled pipeline maintenance.
Exclusive: Andrew Dittmar Expects Increased Public M&A in 2024
2024-02-15 - In this Hart Energy LIVE Exclusive, Andrew Dittmar, Enverus Intelligence's senior vice president, compares 2023 consolidation to what he expects in 2024, including more public to public deals.
Chesapeake Stockpiles DUCs as Doubts Creep in Over Southwestern Deal
2024-05-02 - Chesapeake Energy is stockpiling DUCs until demand returns through growth from LNG exports, power generation and industrial activity.
Enterprise Increasing Permian NatGas Production
2024-04-03 - Enterprise Products Partners began service on two natural gas plants: the Leonidas in the Midland Basin and the Mentone 3 in the Delaware Basin, each with a capacity to process 300 MMcf/d of natural gas and 40,000 bbl/d of NGLs.