At the end of 2014, there were a record 124 MLPs trading. By the end of 2015, that number had fallen to 121, and by the end of 2016 there were only 112. At the end of January 2017, there were 110 and, if all pending mergers are approved, another handful will disappear. The loss of over a dozen companies has begun to worry some investors.
While MLPs are generally insulated from moderate moves in commodity prices, the huge fall in the price of crude oil, combined with minimal recovery, has impacted the more commodity-sensitive MLPs. Many upstream MLPs declared bankruptcy over the past two years and are no longer trading on major exchanges.
Midstream MLPs may be more insulated from commodity price moves but they are not immune. As their customers struggled, and some contracts were not renewed, the fundamentals of midstream MLPs suffered. Negative investor sentiment across the entire energy sector further depressed prices, increasing the cost of equity for MLPs. As leverage ratios rose, so too did the cost of debt.
In order to lower their cost of capital so they could continue to pursue growth, many MLPs bought out a parent’s incentive distribution rights or merged with each other or a parent company. While the bankruptcies of the commodity-sensitive MLPs are indeed worrying, smarter combinations and capital structures will remove growth headwinds.
As MLPs continue to position themselves to pursue growth, 2017 is likely to see more merger and simplification announcements. The space may begin to barbell into a handful of mega-caps and many small- or micro-caps with the result that the largest companies will need to both compete for bids and cooperate when joint ventures are necessary. The smaller midstream companies must find and defend their niches and unique offerings.
With few MLP S-1s filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, indicating plans to go public and create new companies, each company that remains trading can spend the next few years building its individual moat without competition from new entrants.
Consolidation is a natural part of many industries, particularly those which require significant upfront infrastructure investment. As such, the absolute number of MLPs should not be investors’ primary focus when considering the future of the space. More than whether a company is structured as a C corporation or an MLP, its existing footprints, cost of capital and availability of labor will determine how well it is positioned to participate in the buildout of North American energy infrastructure over the next several decades.
Maria Halmo is the director of research at Alerian, an independent provider of MLP and energy infrastructure market intelligence. Over $17 billion is directly tied to the Alerian Index Series. For additional commentary and research, please visit www.alerian.com/alerian-insights.
Recommended Reading
What's Affecting Oil Prices This Week? (April 8, 2024)
2024-04-08 - Stratas Advisors says geopolitics are providing a boost for oil prices as conflicts escalate–and while crude oil and oil products continue to flow, the possibility of disruption is increasing.
Oil Broadly Steady After Surprise US Crude Stock Drop
2024-03-21 - Stockpiles unexpectedly declined by 2 MMbbl to 445 MMbbl in the week ended March 15, as exports rose and refiners continued to increase activity.
US Oil Stockpiles Surge as Prices Dip, Production Remains Elevated
2024-02-14 - EIA reported crude oil stocks increased by 12.8 MMbbl as February began, far outstripping expectations.
US Gulf Coast Heavy Crude Oil Prices Firm as Supplies Tighten
2024-04-10 - Pushing up heavy crude prices are falling oil exports from Mexico, the potential for resumption of sanctions on Venezuelan crude, the imminent startup of a Canadian pipeline and continued output cuts by OPEC+.
US Leads Global Oil Production for Sixth Straight Year-EIA
2024-03-11 - The Energy Information Administration says it is unlikely that the record will be broken by another country in the near term.