A former investment banker landed a so-called incentive fee of $450,000, one of the largest of its kind, for pursuing a securities lawsuit that led to $100 million in damages against Kinder Morgan Inc.
Peter Brinckerhoff of Florida was awarded the fee for putting in more than 1,500 hours on the case, which resulted in one of the largest damage awards in the history of Delaware's Court of Chancery, which heard the case. The lawsuit benefited other investors who did not actively participate in the litigation.
"I don't know if it's the largest ever, but it's remarkably large for a securities case," said Geoffrey Miller, a professor at New York University Law School who has researched incentive awards.
Several plaintiffs and defense attorneys who specialize in securities class action cases said it was the largest incentive award they had seen.
Brinckerhoff brought the suit in 2010 to challenge a deal by El Paso Pipeline Partners, a publicly traded master limited partnership.
Vice Chancellor Travis Laster of the Court of Chancery ruled last year that the MLP overpaid when it acquired pipeline assets from its controlling parent, El Paso Corp. The judge ordered the overpayment returned to El Paso Pipeline's investors.
Kinder Morgan later acquired El Paso, and is on the hook for the damages.
Brinckerhoff had sought $1.35 million, a figure his lawyers conceded in court papers was "unusual," to compensate him for spending five years working on the case.
Brinckerhoff was an investment banker who retired from Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette in 1991, according to court documents. He could not be reached for comment.
Incentive awards have been criticized as "bounties" that encourage wasteful class actions, and in 2003 Congress briefly considered banning them in federal courts.
Laster, who approved the award, has a reputation for being tough on fees when he questions the value of the litigation. In Brinckerhoff's case, Laster awarded $33 million for lawyers with Rosenthal, Monhait & Goddess and Bragar Eagel & Squire.
Lawyers for the law firms did not respond to a request for comment.
Ted Frank, a critic of what he views as abusive tactics in class action cases, said incentive awards are more troubling when they are paid in settlement agreements.
"I don't necessarily have a problem with it," he said of the Brinckerhoff payment.
Recommended Reading
EQT Sees Clear Path to $5B in Potential Divestments
2024-04-24 - EQT Corp. executives said that an April deal with Equinor has been a catalyst for talks with potential buyers.
Matador Hoards Dry Powder for Potential M&A, Adds Delaware Acreage
2024-04-24 - Delaware-focused E&P Matador Resources is growing oil production, expanding midstream capacity, keeping debt low and hunting for M&A opportunities.
TotalEnergies, Vanguard Renewables Form RNG JV in US
2024-04-24 - Total Energies and Vanguard Renewable’s equally owned joint venture initially aims to advance 10 RNG projects into construction during the next 12 months.
Ithaca Energy to Buy Eni's UK Assets in $938MM North Sea Deal
2024-04-23 - Eni, one of Italy's biggest energy companies, will transfer its U.K. business in exchange for 38.5% of Ithaca's share capital, while the existing Ithaca Energy shareholders will own the remaining 61.5% of the combined group.
EIG’s MidOcean Closes Purchase of 20% Stake in Peru LNG
2024-04-23 - MidOcean Energy’s deal for SK Earthon’s Peru LNG follows a March deal to purchase Tokyo Gas’ LNG interests in Australia.