Learn more about Hart Energy Conferences
Get our latest conference schedules, updates and insights straight to your inbox.
HOUSTON—At a recent energy forum, panelists discussed how private equity has remained active in the energy industry during the low price environment.
Overall, acquisition activity in the sector has been constrained, both on the corporate level and for private equity. As upstream and midstream companies rushed to cut costs, the expectation was that those companies that were hurting for capital would divest assets to increase their liquidity. That has turned out not to be the case, as panelists explained.
Mark Burroughs, managing director at EnCap Investments LP, said companies are hanging on to assets as long as possible because everyone expects oil prices to go up.
“Everyone wants to buy at $50 to $60 oil. No one wants to sell,” he said at the Mergermarket Energy Forum on May 19.
Rakesh Wilson, partner at Apollo Management, said that companies, to avoid selling, have strategically raised a lot of debt and equity.
“That has provided a lot of liquidity to the energy businesses, but not for long,” Wilson said. Those companies raising liquidity through debt and equity are essentially playing a waiting game, hoping prices rebound or stabilize before their stop-gap measures become ineffective, he added.
According to Burroughs, “What has to happen, if we’re in a prolonged period of lower prices, at some point when the hedges roll off and the cash flows continue to go down, the banks will have to put pressure on companies to sell assets. It’s just going to happen.”
If and when it does happen, which Burroughs anticipates could be at the end of 2015 or early 2016, lower quality assets would come up for sale first, but high-quality assets would also likely be up for acquisition not long after.
Alternatively, transactions could pick back up if the price of oil stabilized, Burroughs predicted. Many companies remain hesitant to place assets for sale while oil prices are still volatile. If the price settles, even if the price hovers at around $65 per barrel for the near-term, management would feel more comfortable resuming transaction activity.
“When you have stability not only in price but in people's thinking, you start to see more transactions happen,” Burroughs said.
Once transactions resume in the energy space, private equity will likely be right there ready to start doing acquisition deals again, as private equity investment never really slowed down in the space, according to Amber Meek, partner at Kirkland & Ellis LLP.
Rather than slowing down, “it's really more that a lot of our clients started pivoting,” she said.
“The deals that they were looking at, the deals that they were trying to do, did fall by the wayside, and so the fourth-quarter [2014] and the first-quarter [2015] of this year were slow as far as closing deals. But they actually got very busy and started ramping up on alternative transactions, these creative ways of doing things maybe they traditionally hadn't done,” she said. Rather than acquire a working interest in a company, private equity clients might instead buy into company debt or purchase securities of a public company through a PIPE (Private Investment in Public Equity) transaction.
“It wasn’t necessarily that everything just ramped down and [private equity] stopped being active in the market,” she said. “They’re just pivoting to different things and ramping up those deals and saying ‘let the other deals fall off.’”
Contact the author, Caryn Livingston, at clivingston@hartenergy.com.
Recommended Reading
The OGInterview: TG Natural Resources Rides LNG Wave
2024-03-01 - TG Natural Resources rides the LNG wave with its Rockcliff deal amid a shale consolidation boom.
Exclusive: Andrew Dittmar Expects Increased Public M&A in 2024
2024-02-15 - In this Hart Energy LIVE Exclusive, Andrew Dittmar, Enverus Intelligence's senior vice president, compares 2023 consolidation to what he expects in 2024, including more public to public deals.
4Q Deal-Making Was $144B; What’s Next?
2024-01-23 - U.S. takeout targets are few now. Operators may go abroad to add reserves, according to Enverus. Private E&Ps may pick up offshoots from portfolio pruning.
DUG GAS+: Chesapeake in Drill-but-don’t-turn-on Mode
2024-03-28 - COO Josh Viets said Chesapeake is cutting costs and ready to take advantage once gas prices rebound.
Exclusive: Can NatGas Save the 'Fragile' Electric Grid?
2024-02-28 - John Harpole, the founder and president of Mercator Energy, says he is concerned about meeting peak electric demand and if investors will hesitate on making LNG export facilities investment decisions after the Biden administration's recent LNG pause, in this Hart Energy LIVE Exclusive interview.