It appears as though any recoupling that took place between crude oil and NGL prices in the past year was a coincidence more than a return to the old form of normalcy, given the decoupling between the two that took place as the first half ended.
While West Texas Intermediate (WTI) crude has been trading at an average of $60 per barrel (bbl) recently, NGL prices lost nearly 10% in value at the Conway, Kan., and Mont Belvieu, Texas, trad ing hubs. Interestingly, there is more evidence to suggest that prices should recouple on the downward cycle—more than a further widening of the delta between the two markets.
NGL prices are expected to continue to face headwinds throughout the rest of the summer with the possible exception of ethane, which may begin to see improvements. The biggest headwind facing the NGL market is the large storage build for most liquids with ethane being the only product that can reasonably anticipate a tightening of volumes in the near term. This situation has caused most NGL prices to hit their lowest level in nearly a decade.
The global crude market is also oversupplied, but prices have been improving. However, prices may reverse as the market reacts to the large storage levels for crude.
The oil glut hasn’t sufficiently cleared and instead only shifted geography, according to a re- cent Barclays Capital research note. Additionally North American balances have been supported by very few remaining runs, declining output from the Bakken, wildfires in Canada and synthetic crude oil maintenance.
The story is starker for NGL prices, especially for propane, which hit 14-year lows at both Mont Belvieu and Conway. While margins remain positive, the Midcontinent frac spread is very thin. There is a silver lining, though, and that’s the fact that storage builds have been lower than expected the past few weeks as LPG exports grow.
Although propane prices are heading down a similar path that ethane took three years ago, the hope is that they won’t stay at this level for as long as ethane prices. Unlike ethane, propane has multiple outlets: petrochemical, heating and commercial. Ethane only has the North American petrochemical market as a demand center with exports coming on soon.
This isn’t to say that there will be a quick turn-around in the propane market. Short of another polar vortex this winter, prices are likely to improve on an incremental basis as the large storage levels are worked off. It is possible that propane burning will help restore balance in much the same way that ethane rejection is beginning to restore that market.
Recommended Reading
Enbridge Advances Expansion of Permian’s Gray Oak Pipeline
2024-02-13 - In its fourth-quarter earnings call, Enbridge also said the Mainline pipeline system tolling agreement is awaiting regulatory approval from a Canadian regulatory agency.
Canadian Natural Resources Boosting Production in Oil Sands
2024-03-04 - Canadian Natural Resources will increase its quarterly dividend following record production volumes in the quarter.
Kissler: OPEC+ Likely to Buoy Crude Prices—At Least Somewhat
2024-03-18 - By keeping its voluntary production cuts, OPEC+ is sending a clear signal that oil prices need to be sustainable for both producers and consumers.
Moda Midstream II Receives Financial Commitment for Next Round of Development
2024-03-20 - Kingwood, Texas-based Moda Midstream II announced on March 20 that it received an equity commitment from EnCap Flatrock Midstream.
CorEnergy Infrastructure to Reorganize in Pre-packaged Bankruptcy
2024-02-26 - CorEnergy, coming off a January sale of its MoGas and Omega pipeline and gathering systems, filed for bankruptcy protect after reaching an agreement with most of its debtors.