Canadian crude-by-rail exports dipped in the fourth quarter from the previous three-month period, National Energy Board data showed on March 5, as poor netbacks deterred some shippers from loading barrels onto trains bound for U.S. markets.
Canada exported 173,342 barrels per day (bbl/d) of crude by rail between October and December last year, down 5% from 182,396 bbl/d shipped across the border in the third quarter.
However, fourth-quarter rail exports were still 16% higher than the same period a year earlier.
The quarter-on-quarter slowdown underlines how weak oil prices are putting the brakes on the North American crude-by-rail boom.
Benchmark oil prices around $50/bbl and tight Canadian crude differentials around $14/bbl below U.S. crude means some routes have become uneconomic.
“The differentials have come in quite a bit so they just have not been covering the railing costs,” said Martin King, analyst at FirstEnergy Capital.
Canada’s largest producer, Suncor Energy, no longer ships crude by rail from northern Alberta to the U.S. Gulf Coast, despite strong demand for Canadian heavy crude in North America’s largest refining area.
The journey is no longer economic, Suncor CEO Steve Williams said in February, adding that crude-by-rail into the company's 137,000 bbl/d Montreal refinery was “marginal.”
Slower growth means a Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers forecast of 700,000 bbl/d of Canadian crude being transported by rail by the end of 2016 may be hard to reach.
“I suspect there may be some dampening on that,” said Greg Stringham, CAPP’s vice president of oil sands and markets. “Early indications are with low oil prices and the higher cost of rail it is tough to continue that (pace) going forward.”
Canadian Pacific Railway, one of the country’s two major railroads, has downgraded its 2015 crude-by-rail forecast to 140,000 carloads from 200,000 carloads previously.
New loading terminals starting up this year such as Kinder Morgan Inc. and Imperial Oil Ltd.’s facility in Edmonton, Alberta, and a Plains Midstream Canada terminal in Saskatchewan mean Canadian crude-by-rail loadings will continue to grow, albeit at a slower pace than previously expected.
Glen Perry, vice president of marketing at privately held junior Grizzly Oil Sands, said netbacks on crude-by-rail were “horrible” but that some small producers without pipeline connections had no alternative.
“We would lose money going anywhere (by rail), so the question is where do we lose the least amount,” he said.
Recommended Reading
Range Resources Holds Production Steady in 1Q 2024
2024-04-24 - NGLs are providing a boost for Range Resources as the company waits for natural gas demand to rebound.
Hess Midstream Increases Class A Distribution
2024-04-24 - Hess Midstream has increased its quarterly distribution per Class A share by approximately 45% since the first quarter of 2021.
Baker Hughes Awarded Saudi Pipeline Technology Contract
2024-04-23 - Baker Hughes will supply centrifugal compressors for Saudi Arabia’s new pipeline system, which aims to increase gas distribution across the kingdom and reduce carbon emissions
PrairieSky Adds $6.4MM in Mannville Royalty Interests, Reduces Debt
2024-04-23 - PrairieSky Royalty said the acquisition was funded with excess earnings from the CA$83 million (US$60.75 million) generated from operations.
Equitrans Midstream Announces Quarterly Dividends
2024-04-23 - Equitrans' dividends will be paid on May 15 to all applicable ETRN shareholders of record at the close of business on May 7.